Skip to main content
UK - Financial Adviser
Select Region Select User Type
  • Global
    • Home
  • UK Investors
    • Financial Adviser
    • Private Investor
  • International Investors
    • Private Investor
    • Professional Investor
  • Fund Centre
    • Our Funds
      • Equities
        • Rathbone Global Opportunities Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund
        • Rathbone Income Fund Fund
        • Rathbone UK Opportunities Fund
      • Fixed Income
        • Rathbone Ethical bond Fund
        • Rathbone High Quality Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Strategic Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainable Bond Fund
      • Multi-Asset
        • Rathbone Greenbank Multi-Asset Portfolios
        • Rathbone MULTI-ASSET PORTFOLIOS
      • Sustainable
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainable Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Multi-Asset Portfolios
    • Literature Library
    • Consumer Duty
    • Prices and Performance
    • Glossary of Terms and FAQs
  • Strategies
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Multi-Asset
    • Sustainable
  • Our Clients
    • Private Investor
    • Financial Adviser
    • International Private Investor
    • International Financial Adviser
  • Rathbones
  • Global Home
  • Insights
    • Fund Insights
    • In the know blog
    • Review of the week
    • The Sharpe End podcast
  • About us
    • About us
    • Our People
    • Awards
    • Media centre
    • Responsible Investing at Rathbones
  • Contact
Home Home

Search

  • Fund Centre
    • Our Funds
      • Equities
        • Rathbone Global Opportunities Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund
        • Rathbone Income Fund Fund
        • Rathbone UK Opportunities Fund
      • Fixed Income
        • Rathbone Ethical bond Fund
        • Rathbone High Quality Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Strategic Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainable Bond Fund
      • Multi-Asset
        • Rathbone Greenbank Multi-Asset Portfolios
        • Rathbone MULTI-ASSET PORTFOLIOS
      • Sustainable
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainable Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Multi-Asset Portfolios
    • Literature Library
    • Consumer Duty
    • Prices and Performance
    • Glossary of Terms and FAQs
  • Strategies
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Multi-Asset
    • Sustainable
  • Our Clients
    • Private Investor
    • Financial Adviser
    • International Private Investor
    • International Financial Adviser
  • Rathbones
  • Global Home
  • Insights
    • Fund Insights
    • In the know blog
    • Review of the week
    • The Sharpe End podcast
  • About us
    • About us
    • Our People
    • Awards
    • Media centre
    • Responsible Investing at Rathbones
  • Contact
Home

Search

Thinking for yourself

Don’t let robots blindly guide you, warns David Coombs, our head of multi-asset investments. Algorithms are great investors right up to the point when things change – which is more often than programmers would like.

9 April 2019

There’s nothing like a week away in Cornwall to step out of the daily rush and rest up. After my fair share of sleepy country lanes and coastline walks I’m back more than ready for the second-quarter assault.

It’s always interesting coming back to your commute and seeing what subtle changes have happened while you were away. New hoardings at the station never fail to liven up even the saddest regular commuter’s morning.

Imagine my exuberance on stumbling onto this absolute gem a whole trail of walking men (not sure that’s allowed in Woke Land) painted onto the pavement to remind passengers alighting at Swindon that they should walk on the pavement. Now Swindon (or Greater Cotswolds) is special (we are getting the biggest IMAX in Europe), but pavements are not some innovative development peculiar to Wiltshire as far as I am aware.

I do feel (old man rant coming) that society is becoming so enthralled by technology that it underestimates the most powerful computer of all – the human brain. Take quant strategies, for example.

If you watch Billions – and you really should – there is big struggle between Axe, the fundamental hedge fund manager, and Taylor who believes quant/algorithmic strategies are more powerful. I am with Axe, I’m afraid, because I think humans can better adapt and take advantages of opportunities. Algorithms (algos) are programmed in a certain environment and can only operate as long as it doesn’t swing, change or shift. That’s arguably why algo funds have performed terribly in the past year or so of erratic markets.

Many quant or risk-targeted strategies reduce risk when volatility rises. Just think about that for a moment. Volatility typically rises at inflection points, so it tends to spike on corrections. An algo model is therefore telling you to take risk out to keep within your target at precisely the time you should be buying. And then, once market sentiment rallies and indices recover, volatility falls and your model encourages you to take on more risk. You end up selling low and buying high in erratic markets. This is nonsensical.

Of course, more sophisticated models in high-frequency strategies that are arbitraging small gains in microseconds may be able to eke out returns, but any long-term investment by this logic seems fundamentally flawed to me.

Our funds have risk budgets and often when markets are going up our nominal volatility falls. Even if we have matched our return targets and have high-risk adjusted returns we are challenged for not taking enough risk. “Returns are good but you could have had more,” some argue. This is very dangerous territory. I know that at these times my potential (or implied) volatility is much higher than my historic (or realised) volatility. If I ignore this and add risk in response to the criticism then I will increase my participation significantly just before an inflection point. In the parlance, I’ll be no better than a dumb robot following numbers from the past.

That’s the difference between me and the fund manager computer model: I know I can’t predict what will happen and I know that the past doesn’t inform the future. For me, this is common sense; for the algorithmic model, it just means “load up.”

Having managed money for 30 years or more (old man rant again), I feel able to push back on this analysis rather than capitulate to get the buy rating. I may lose out on new fund flows in the short term, but my track record is more important in the long run.

Common sense is a much underrated input in asset management land. I think it will make a comeback now volatility is back to stay. I can’t be so confident about Swindon council though!

Images by David Coombs. 

Most popular blogs

29 February 2024

Nvidia: from pastime to new paradigm

A business created to make computer game graphics more beautiful stumbled into driving AI, one of the most important technologies of the 21st century. Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund manager David Harrison explains what all the fuss is about.

Find out more

5 mins

4 December 2024

Why active management has a place in 2025 and beyond

The rise of passive investment is storing up risks that many investors may not realise they are taking. James Crossley, our head of Rathbones Asset Management distribution, makes the case for active managers.

Find out more

3 mins

9 January 2024

2024: The Year. Maybe?

Our head of multi-asset investments David Coombs starts the new year making a three-point turn with a dump truck of salt. Behold, we have his predictions.

Find out more

3 mins

18 January 2024

Ceasing to worship at the altar of stock-pickers

Back in secondary school, our head of multi-asset investments David Coombs was a champion stock-picker. Although, he had help from his teacher’s direct line to the market – which taught him markets tend to be unfair.

Find out more

4 mins

In The KNOW blog

Read the latest news and views from our fund managers

Blog posts

Subscribe to the In The KNOW blog

You can unsubscribe at any time. For details on how we handle your data, visit our Privacy policy.

CAPTCHA

Let's Talk

Ready to start a conversation? Please complete our enquiry form, we look forward to speaking with you

Enquire
  • Important Information
    • Brexit Statement
    • Important information
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    • Accessibility
    • Privacy
    • Cookies
    • Cookie preferences
    • Complaints
  • Important Information
    • Consumer Duty
    • Voting disclosure
    • Assessment of value reports
    • TCFD Reports
    • SDR Consumer-Facing Disclosures
    • Financial Ombudsman Service
    • Financial Services Compensation Scheme
    • Glossary of terms and FAQs
    • MIFIDPRU8
Address

Rathbones Asset Management
30 Gresham Street
London
EC2V 7QN

Rathbones Asset Management Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and a member of the Investment Association. A member of the Rathbone Group. Registered Office 30 Gresham Street, London EC2V 7QN. Registered in England No 02376568.

© 2025 Rathbones Group Plc
Incorporated and registered in England and Wales. Registered number 01000403

Follow us
LinkedIn
City Hive Logo
ACT Logo

Rathbones Asset Management is delighted to be an early signatory of the ACT Framework created by City Hive

Diversity Project Logo

Rathbones Asset Management is a member of The Diversity Project

The value of your investments and the income from them may go down as well as up, and you could get back less than you invested.