Skip to main content
UK - Financial Adviser
Select Region Select User Type
  • Global
    • Home
  • UK Investors
    • Financial Adviser
    • Private Investor
  • International Investors
    • Private Investor
    • Professional Investor
  • Fund Centre
    • Our Funds
      • Equities
        • Rathbone Global Opportunities Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund
        • Rathbone Income Fund Fund
        • Rathbone UK Opportunities Fund
      • Fixed Income
        • Rathbone Ethical bond Fund
        • Rathbone High Quality Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Strategic Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainable Bond Fund
      • Multi-Asset
        • Rathbone Greenbank Multi-Asset Portfolios
        • Rathbone MULTI-ASSET PORTFOLIOS
      • Sustainable
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainable Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Multi-Asset Portfolios
    • Literature Library
    • Consumer Duty
    • Prices and Performance
    • Glossary of Terms and FAQs
  • Strategies
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Multi-Asset
    • Sustainable
  • Our Clients
    • Private Investor
    • Financial Adviser
    • International Private Investor
    • International Financial Adviser
  • Rathbones
  • Global Home
  • Insights
    • Fund Insights
    • In the know blog
    • Review of the week
    • The Sharpe End podcast
  • About us
    • About us
    • Our People
    • Awards
    • Media centre
    • Responsible Investing at Rathbones
  • Contact
Home Home

Search

  • Fund Centre
    • Our Funds
      • Equities
        • Rathbone Global Opportunities Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund
        • Rathbone Income Fund Fund
        • Rathbone UK Opportunities Fund
      • Fixed Income
        • Rathbone Ethical bond Fund
        • Rathbone High Quality Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Strategic Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainable Bond Fund
      • Multi-Asset
        • Rathbone Greenbank Multi-Asset Portfolios
        • Rathbone MULTI-ASSET PORTFOLIOS
      • Sustainable
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainable Bond Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Global Sustainability Fund
        • Rathbone Greenbank Multi-Asset Portfolios
    • Literature Library
    • Consumer Duty
    • Prices and Performance
    • Glossary of Terms and FAQs
  • Strategies
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Multi-Asset
    • Sustainable
  • Our Clients
    • Private Investor
    • Financial Adviser
    • International Private Investor
    • International Financial Adviser
  • Rathbones
  • Global Home
  • Insights
    • Fund Insights
    • In the know blog
    • Review of the week
    • The Sharpe End podcast
  • About us
    • About us
    • Our People
    • Awards
    • Media centre
    • Responsible Investing at Rathbones
  • Contact
Home

Search

The case for UK equity income

The pandemic and the global lockdowns to combat its spread have raised havoc with UK dividends. Yet that very disruption could lead to better managed companies and more sustainable dividends, argues Income Fund manager Carl Stick.

17 June 2020

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Knowledge and Insight
  3. The case for UK equity income

Article last updated 19 February 2023.

There’s a point in 12 Angry Men when 11 jurors vote guilty and Henry Fonda becomes a holdout. Everyone believes the man on trial is guilty, the evidence is undisputed. They all want to get the job over and done with and get to the baseball match. Yet Fonda, annoyingly, refuses to budge.   These days, as an equity income investor, I feel a lot like Fonda’s Juror 8. I feel like I need to give account of why I think the prosecution and all the other jurors are wrong about UK dividend stocks.  

UK Equity Income was ailing before the pandemic

Concerns about the future of UK equity income started in the Before Times, the pandemic and its consequences have simply upped the ante. Yet I believe the shock of the pandemic will actually deal with the underlying issue that has dogged UK dividend-payers for years. At root, the UK Equity Income sector’s commitment to outdo the yield of the FTSE All-Share Index became a problem when the yield of that index became unbalanced and unsustainable. For many years, the UK has been the go-to market for dividends and companies did their utmost to provide. 

"I believe 2020 must be the impetus to redefine what equity income means. Equity income isn’t dead. But quixotically chasing dividend yield most certainly should be." Yet a confluence of falling interest rates and seismic shifts in industries that accounted for a large part of the FTSE led many UK companies to come unstuck in their quest for ever-increasing payouts. Broadly, many of them raised cheap debt to paper over the cracks in cash flows, creating an unsustainable path that contorted their balance sheets and curtailed their ability to reinvest in their businesses. Back in 2017, the IA had to loosen the UK Equity Income yield requirements because the index yield began to balloon as the dividends paid by many large companies looked dicey. Few companies felt they could cut their payouts without causing an almighty fall in their share prices.   And then the pandemic came. Many of these businesses were forced to reduce, defer or cancel their dividends. For some, this was inevitable: if your market is closed, if your customers are in lockdown, you cannot generate revenue, so you can’t make profits. Then there is the moral question about paying cash to shareholders when staff are on furlough. So much has happened that was out of companies’ control. Yet, ironically, this could give companies more control in the future. The pandemic is a perfect excuse for these companies to reset their strategies, their investment plans and their dividends.   

Now is a time for UK dividend payers to reset 

"For too long in the UK there has been too great a concentration of dividend income being generated by too few stocks, many of which have been anchored to maintaining these payouts regardless of other priorities and – in some cases – common sense. "

How businesses allocate their capital ultimately determines the level of their future profits and also whether those profits can be sustained. Those sustainably growing profits are the bedrock for a sustainable, growing dividend. The cash returned to shareholders should be the by-product of prudent, sustainable investment in a business. It shouldn’t be the overarching aim that then determines how a business deploys its capital; that leads to over-indebtedness and an insidious squeeze on reinvestment that snowballs down the years. I think UK dividend-payers will now be able to reset themselves and enter an era of more sustainable dividends for their shareholders.    My defence of UK equity income is established upon an honest reckoning of the ill-discipline that has accompanied the cash returns to shareholders over the past decade. Cheap funding enabled businesses to over-distribute cash, while ignoring the investment needed to lay the foundation for future growth. For too long in the UK there has been too great a concentration of dividend income being generated by too few stocks, many of which have been anchored to maintaining these payouts regardless of other priorities and – in some cases – common sense.    I believe 2020 must be the impetus to redefine what equity income means. Equity income isn’t dead. But quixotically chasing dividend yield most certainly should be. As for Juror 8, he turned out to be right in the end: the evidence was circumstantial, other jurors were conflating the crime with problems in their own lives and the case wasn’t as clean cut as it first seemed.   Give it a little time, and I feel the charges against UK equity income will also come unstuck.

Popular Articles

9341_multi-asset_webinar_cm.jpg
26 February 2025

Multi-Asset Webcast | February 2025

We are delighted to invite you to our upcoming webcast with Will McIntosh-Whyte, fund manager of the Rathbone Multi-Asset Portfolios.

Find out more

1 min

ethical bond fund field
30 April 2025

Ethical Bond Webcast | April 2025

After a period of volatility in risk markets, Bryn will give his views on the outlook for rates and credit markets and will go into how the Washington whack-a-mole politics are creating very short-term volatility.

Find out more

1 min

9341_multi-asset_webinar_cm.jpg
14 May 2025

Multi-Asset Webcast | May 2025

Join David Coombs, Head of Multi-Asset Investments of the Rathbone Multi-Asset Portfolios, for his next webcast on Wednesday 14 May at 10.00 am.

Find out more

1 min

MOST READ
  1. Multi-Asset Webcast | February 2025

  2. Ethical Bond Webcast | April 2025

  3. Multi-Asset Webcast | May 2025

  4. Review of the week: The emperor's new tariffs

  5. Review of the week: Gloves off?

Let's Talk

Ready to start a conversation? Please complete our enquiry form, we look forward to speaking with you

Enquire
  • Important Information
    • Brexit Statement
    • Important information
    • UK Modern Slavery Act
    • Accessibility
    • Privacy
    • Cookies
    • Cookie preferences
    • Complaints
  • Important Information
    • Consumer Duty
    • Voting disclosure
    • Assessment of value reports
    • TCFD Reports
    • SDR Consumer-Facing Disclosures
    • Financial Ombudsman Service
    • Financial Services Compensation Scheme
    • Glossary of terms and FAQs
    • MIFIDPRU8
Address

Rathbones Asset Management
30 Gresham Street
London
EC2V 7QN

Rathbones Asset Management Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and a member of the Investment Association. A member of the Rathbone Group. Registered Office 30 Gresham Street, London EC2V 7QN. Registered in England No 02376568.

© 2025 Rathbones Group Plc
Incorporated and registered in England and Wales. Registered number 01000403

Follow us
LinkedIn
City Hive Logo
ACT Logo

Rathbones Asset Management is delighted to be an early signatory of the ACT Framework created by City Hive

Diversity Project Logo

Rathbones Asset Management is a member of The Diversity Project

The value of your investments and the income from them may go down as well as up, and you could get back less than you invested.